The energy sector is a risk-averse industry with good reason – if something goes wrong, it goes terribly wrong for many people (like Deepwater Horizon or Fukushima). Disruption at the power plant level is not as easy or exciting as it might be in other markets.
Over the past few years, however, the industry has had to confront a new paradigm as we have moved from fears of climate change to the reality of climate crisis. This threat to our climate requires bold action, which energy giant Enel addresses with a unique approach. In “a sector that cannot make mistakes”, as Enel CEO Francesco Starace says, the company has “used sustainability as a stimulus to innovation”.
From state-owned to record profits
Enel began as Italy’s national electricity company in the 1960s. After privatisation in the 1990s, it became an international power company as it expanded into Spain, Latin America and North America in the early 2000s. One of the largest power utility companies in the world with €80 billion in revenues in 2019, Enel has also been moving away from fossil fuels for some time by further investing in renewables (e.g. hydro, solar, wind and geothermal).
The renewable power industry has blown up over the past decade. In 2004, global annual investment in renewables amounted to US$47 billion. Just 13 years later, it reached US$280 billion. In 2019, Enel (through Enel Green Power) was the world’s biggest privately-owned renewable energy operator.
Starace, the force behind Enel Green Power, was appointed CEO of Enel in 2014. His mandate was to create long-term sustainable value for all Enel’s stakeholders. To do this, the company would adhere to the UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) to guide investment decisions. Now, not only do these goals guide Enel’s investments, they are also integral to a new financial instrument. In 2019, the company launched the world’s first general-purpose SDG-linked bonds.
In a recent case study, “Enel’s Innovability: Global Open Innovation and Sustainability”, co-authored with José Miguel García (INSEAD MBA ‘19J), we look at how Enel has managed to thrive via innovation and sustainability in uncertain times for the energy sector.
Naturally, before investing in disruption, a complete change of mindset at Enel was necessary. “Fear of making mistakes is a really terrible environment for innovation,” Starace commented. “It is toxic.”
The vision of sustainable energy through disruption was there, but Enel needed someone to realise it with the company. Ernesto Ciorra, Enel’s Chief Innovability Officer, created the Innovability department – a portmanteau of innovation and sustainability. Soon after, to help change the corporate mindset that didn’t allow for mistakes, Ciorra launched the internal platform called “My Best Failure” to encourage Enel’s employees to share their biggest failures and lessons learned from these hurdles.
Instead of relying on innovation only from within Enel’s business units, Ciorra started looking outside to see how it could be integrated into the energy giant. This kind of open innovation required even more changes in the culture and structure of Enel. Previously, each distinct part of the company had its own R&D department and these teams were not quick to share information. Now, Innovability teams are an integrated part of each business line and report to Ciorra. A large digitalisation project followed in accordance with SDG 9: Industry, innovation and infrastructure.
The next jump was pulling innovation from the outside into the company with a crowdsourcing innovation platform. Using OpenInnovability, thousands of “solvers” were able to contribute solutions to challenges. Instead of thinking outside the box, the company has invited those from outside to consider problems in ways that haven’t yet been considered. One example is saving resources on an essential ingredient in geothermal plant thanks to a novel solution from a biologist, an outsider who has a different approach to the problems that engineers face on a daily basis.
Pulling in that outside innovation was important, and doing so on a larger scale, with global open innovation, which incorporates the best ideas from around the world into a firm, has had a tremendous impact. In 2016, Enel opened its first innovation hub in Tel Aviv. Starace described the thinking behind the decision of opening a centre outside of traditional energy company locations: “This is a compact environment with highly concentrated amount of smart people. The reason for the entrepreneurial background is that it’s rooted in the system with a strong academic link.”
At a presentation at INSEAD for SDG Week, Enel’s Head of Innovation Hubs Fabio Tentori (INSEAD MBA ’10) said, “Each ecosystem is peculiar and brings a variety of opportunities and benefits to Enel.” He is the leader of the ten innovation hubs worldwide with a large variety in their output. Challenges vary depending on the innovation hub’s market, but the link among the hubs is the way that SDGs underpin new ideas. One priority for Enel is to ensure that the innovation hubs are close to the expertise each area is known for to bring together the right talent in the right location.
“In traditional accelerator locations like Boston or San Francisco, Enel faces a lot of competition when it comes to convincing start-ups to work together,” Tentori said. For less-known centres, like Chile or Russia, the challenge sometimes lies in convincing business lines to work with start-ups from emerging markets. The energy company grants the opportunity to scale up solutions developed by start-ups on its assets and markets around the world.
For all the innovation hubs, there is a clear process that includes a use case and draws on the SDGs. “All of what we do is driven by reaching sustainable goals,” Tentori said. The cost of innovation is high, yet global open innovation works out better than a closed lab would. “Failing faster is good,” he remarked.
For him personally, listening is a vital part of his work. Listening to start-ups, innovators and competitors “helps me to open up my mind”.
Innovating for good
To truly effect innovation in a risk-averse organisation, a real change of mindset is required. Another risk-averse industry, banking, is also evolving to understand how it can support real change. In January 2020, ECB head Christine Lagarde spoke about how, for firms, “failing to act is already failing” when it comes to climate change. Clearly, business needs to innovate to improve the climate and society.
Enel’s SDG-linked bonds provide transparency for investors on the evolution of its entire business model to address the energy transition. The bonds’ issue was oversubscribed by nearly three times, with orders totalling around US$4 billion. With its desire to transform, Enel has been recognised as a company that can “change the world”. The way forward is using sustainability as an engine to innovate.
Felipe Monteiro is a Senior Affiliate Professor of Strategy at INSEAD. He is also the Academic Director of the Global Talent Competitiveness Index. He is the Programme Director for INSEAD’s partner programme with Fundação Dom Cabral, Advanced Management Program (PGA).
This article is republished courtesy of INSEAD Knowledge. Copyright INSEAD 2020. The opinions expressed in this publication are those of the authors. They do not purport to reflect the opinions or views of Bank of Singapore Limited or its affiliates.
Disclaimer applicable to recommendation
The contents of this presentation have not been prepared or reviewed by Bank of Singapore Limited (the “Bank”). The Bank is not responsible for the accuracy or completeness of the information contained in this presentation which may change without prior notice. If you have any questions regarding the presentation, please refer your questions to the presenter. This presentation may contain views which are not representative of the views of the Bank, and such views may have been derived without discussion, consultation or agreement with the Bank. You will need to decide as to whether or not the contents are suitable for you. When you are in doubt, please seek your own independent financial, legal, tax or other advice as you deem fit. Neither the Bank nor any of its officers accept any liability for any loss whatsoever arising out of or in connection with your use of the information in the presentation.
Australia: Bank of Singapore Limited (i) is exempt from the requirement to hold an Australian financial services (AFS) licence under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) in respect of all financial products or financial services it provides in accordance with ASIC Class Order 03/1102 (as continued in force by ASIC Corporations (Repeal and Transitional) Instrument 2016/396) to any person in Australia who is a wholesale client, and (ii) is regulated by the Monetary Authority of Singapore under Singaporean laws which differ from Australian laws. Brunei: This document has not been delivered to, licensed or permitted by the Autoriti Monetari Brunei Darussalam, the authority as designated under the Brunei Darussalam Securities Markets Order, 2013 and the Banking Order, 2006; nor has it been registered with the Registrar of Companies, Registrar of International Business Companies or the Brunei Darussalam Ministry of Finance. The products mentioned in this document are not registered, licensed or permitted by the Autoriti Monetari Brunei Darussalam or by any other government agency or under any law in Brunei Darussalam. Any offers, acceptances, sales and allotments of the products shall be made outside Brunei Darussalam. Hong Kong SAR: Bank of Singapore Limited is an Authorized Institution as defined in the Banking Ordinance of Hong Kong (Cap 155), regulated by the Hong Kong Monetary Authority in Hong Kong and a Registered Institution as defined in the Securities and Futures Ordinance of Hong Kong (Cap. 571), regulated by the Securities and Futures Commission in Hong Kong. Indonesia: The offering of the investment product in reliance of this document is not registered under the Indonesian Capital Market Law and its implementing regulations, and is not intended to constitute a public offering of securities under the Indonesian Capital Market Law and its implementing regulations. According, this investment product may not be offered or sold, directly or indirectly, within Indonesia or to citizens (wherever they are domiciled or located), entities or residents, in any manner which constitutes a public offering of securities under the Indonesian Capital Market Law and its implementing regulations. Japan: The information contained in this document is for general reference purposes only. It does not have regard to your specific investment objectives, financial situation, risk tolerance and particular needs. Nothing in this document constitutes an offer to buy or sell or an invitation to offer to buy or sell or a recommendation or a solicitation to buy or sell any securities or investment. We do not have any intention of conducting regulated business in Japan. You acknowledge that nothing in this document constitutes investment or financial advice or any advice of any nature. Malaysia: Bank of Singapore Limited does not hold any licence, registration or approval to carry on any regulated business in Malaysia (including but not limited to any businesses regulated under the Capital Markets & Services Act 2007 of Malaysia), nor does it hold itself out as carrying on or purport to carry on any such business in Malaysia. Any services provided by Bank of Singapore Limited to residents of Malaysia are provided solely on an offshore basis from outside Malaysia, either as a result of “reverse enquiry” on the part of the Malaysian residents or where Bank of Singapore Limited has been retained outside Malaysia to provide such services. As an integral part of the provision of such services from outside Malaysia, Bank of Singapore Limited may from time to time make available to such residents documents and information making reference to capital markets products (for example, in connection with the provision of fund management or investment advisory services outside of Malaysia). Nothing in such documents or information is intended to be construed as or constitute the making available of, or an offer or invitation to subscribe for or purchase any such capital markets product. Myanmar: The provision of any products and services by Bank of Singapore Limited shall be solely on an offshore basis. You shall ensure that you have and will continue to be fully compliant with all applicable laws in Myanmar when entering into discussion or contracts with Bank of Singapore Limited. Oman: This document does not constitute a public offer of investment, securities or financial services in the Sultanate of Oman, as contemplated by the Commercial Companies Law of Oman (Royal Decree No. 4/1974), Banking Law of Oman (Royal Decree No. 114/2000) or the Capital Market Law of Oman (Royal Decree No. 80/1998) and the Executive Regulations of the Capital Market Law (Ministerial Decision No. 1/2009) or an offer to sell or the solicitation of any offer to buy non-Omani investment products, securities or financial services and products in the Sultanate of Oman. This document is strictly private and confidential. It is being provided to a limited number of sophisticated investors solely to enable them to decide whether or not to make an offer to invest in financial products mentioned in this document, outside of the Sultanate of Oman, upon the terms and subject to the restrictions set out herein and may not be reproduced or used for any other purpose or provided to any person other than the original recipient. Additionally, this document is not intended to lead to the making of any contract within the territory or under the laws of the Sultanate of Oman. The Capital Market Authority of Oman and the Central Bank of Oman take no responsibility for the accuracy of the statements and information contained in this document or for the performance of the financial products mentioned in this document nor shall they have any liability to any person for damage or loss resulting from reliance on any statement or information contained herein. Russia: The investment products mentioned in this document have not been registered with or approved by the local regulator of any country and are not publicly distributed in Singapore or elsewhere. This document does not constitute or form part of an offer or invitation to the public in any country to subscribe for the products referred to herein. South Korea: The document does not constitute an offer, solicitation or investment advertisement to trade in the investment product referred to in the document. The Philippines: The information contained in this document is not intended to constitute a public offering of securities under the Securities Regulation Code of the Philippines. Dubai International Financial Center (DIFC): Bank of Singapore Limited has a branch registered in the Dubai International Financial Centre ("DIFC") which is regulated by the Dubai Financial Services Authority (“DFSA”). Bank of Singapore Limited (DIFC Branch) is not a financial institution licensed in the United Arab Emirates outside of the DIFC and does not undertake banking or financial activities in the United Arab Emirates nor is it licensed to do so outside of the DIFC. This material is provided for information purposes only and it is general information not specific in any way to any particular investor, investor type, strategy, investment need or other financial circumstance. As such this information is not financial advice or a financial promotion, nor is it intended to influence an investor's decision to invest. It is not to be construed as an offer to buy or sell or solicitation of an offer to buy or sell any financial instruments or to participate in any particular trading strategy in any jurisdiction. The material is only intended for persons who fulfill the criteria to be classified as “Professional Clients” as defined under the DFSA rules and should not be reviewed, received, provided to or relied upon by any other person. United Arab Emirates (U.A.E): The information contained herein is exclusively addressed to the recipient. The offering of certain products in this document has not been and will not be registered with the Central Bank of United Arab Emirates or Securities & Commodities Authority in the United Arab Emirates. Any products in this document that are being offered or sold do not constitute a public offering or distribution of securities under the applicable laws and regulations of the United Arab Emirates. This document is not intended for circulation or distribution in or into the UAE, other than to persons in the UAE to whom such circulation or distribution is permitted by, or is exempt from the requirements of, the applicable laws and regulations of the United Arab Emirates. The distribution of the information contained herein by the recipient is prohibited. Where applicable, this document relates to securities which are listed outside of the Abu Dhabi Securities Exchange and the Dubai Financial Market. The Bank of Singapore Limited is not authorized to provide investment research regarding securities listed on the exchanges of the United Arab Emirates which are outside of the DIFC. United Kingdom: In the United Kingdom, this document is being made available only to the person or the entity to whom it is directed being persons to whom it may lawfully be directed under applicable laws and regulations of the United Kingdom (such persons are hereinafter referred to as ‘relevant persons’). Accordingly, this document is communicated only to relevant persons. Persons who are not relevant persons must not act on or rely on this document or any of its contents. Any investment or investment activity to which this document relates is available only to relevant persons and will be engaged in only with relevant persons. Relevant persons in receipt of this document must not distribute, publish, reproduce, or disclose this document (in whole or in part) to any person who is not a relevant person. United States of America: This product may not be sold or offered within the United States or to U.S. persons. In Hong Kong, Bank of Singapore Limited is a branch of Bank of Singapore Limited incorporated in Singapore with limited liability.
© 2019 Bank of Singapore Limited. All rights reserved.
Version: December 2019